Brew In A Bag : A Simple and Complete Illustrated Guide

Brew in a bag is the perfect way to start all grain brewing – the techniques are simple and the results are great.

This detailed guide explains how to do it.

Brew in a Bag

Brew in a Bag History

Brew in a bag (BIAB) originated in Australia and was initially considered controversial. Many brewers believed it produced inferior beer to all grain methods. However, nowadays it’s use is fairly widespread.

The innovation of BIAB was to combine the benefits of all grain brewing, such as greater choice of ingredients and more control over flavour, with the minimalism of extract brewing, where everything takes place in a single brew pot.

Its simplicity is ideal for beginner brewers who can’t wait to start all grain brewing.

Traditional all grain brewing involves many steps such as steeping malt in a mash tun (often a modified ice chest) before rinsing multiple times in a process known as sparging.

Calculations are performed to ensure that the temperatures and quantities of water and malt are in harmony. The wort (water with malt sugars) that is extracted at the end is boiled and fermented.

That this complicated procedure was developed before one so simple (and effective) is bizarre. Nevertheless, that is the accepted history of the subject.

Equipment For Brew In A Bag

If you already brew with beer kits or malt extract, you should have most of the brewing equipment needed for BIAB.

In addition to the basic kit you’ll also need:

  • a bag

Yes. The only other item you’ll absolutely need to get is a bag made of any light weave, strong fabric. Mine is from a material similar to linen:

brew in a bag bag

The most economical bag is the one you make yourself. In fact, as BIAB is still finding its feet you may struggle to buy a made for brewers bag.

If you opt to make your own, when selecting a fabric choose a strong one. By this I mean that it is able to hold 10-15 kg without breaking. The fabric will act as a filter, holding grains while liquid drains quickly through it. A popular material for many brewers is voile.

An oft-cited limitation of brew in a bag is the inability to brew strong beers due to the difficulty of lifting large amounts of grain from the brew pot. A strong handle will go some way to alleviating this problem.

(Some brewers rig pulley gear to lift the bag from the pot but this is beyond the ambitions of my minimalist setup.)

A good discussion of brew in a bag in general can be found in this article, for anyone interested in finding out more.

Depending on your equipment setup you might consider getting a false bottom for your boil pot.

During the BIAB mash stage, you leave malt (inside the bag) standing in the brew pot, which is filled with hot water.

Malt near the bottom, that is close to the hot stove, will burn unless steps are taken. Many manufacturers supply made to measure disks that fit snugly.

However, a stainless steel colander works equally well:

brew in a bag : false bottom

The perforated false bottom lifts the grains from the bed of the brew pot but allows water to circulate freely through it.

Brew In A Bag In A Nutshell

A quick guide to brew in a bag:

Malt is put into a bag and soaked in water of a pre-determined temperature.

After an hour or so the bag is removed and drained, leaving behind a sugary liquid known as wort.

This is boiled with hops that are added to contribute bitterness, aroma and taste. After cooling, the wort is aerated and yeast are added before the wort is fermented for around two weeks.

The resulting beer is bottled or kegged.

To find out when I publish more brewing guides like this sign up for emails:

A Typical Brew Day

The following photos and instructions describe use this English bitter recipe as an example. The steps are the same for any recipe.

1. Prepare The Brew Pot

brew in a bag : heating the water

Fill the brew pot with the water. Unlike with all grain brewing, you will mash with the full boil volume of water.

Unfortunately there aren’t any hard and fast rules about how much water to add, but as a general rule of thumb you’ll need 30 – 50% more than your target volume.

Water is lost to the grains, to evaporation, and to the hop residue that’s left in the pot. A well-draining bag will reduce loses, as will brewing lighter beers (with less grains), and using an efficient stove.

After a couple of brews you’ll have an idea of your own setup’s performance and can adjust the water quantities accordingly. For the English bitter recipe I use 21 litres of water to yield 14-16 litres of beer.

Heat your water to 1°C more than the target mash temperature of the recipe, to allow for cooling caused by the grain addition. When it’s ready, line the pot with your brew bag.

brew in a bag : bag

2. Add The Malt

Weigh the malt according to the requirements of the recipe.

brew in a bag : weighing grain

Take care not to introduce excess air when adding it to the brew pot, or oxidation will occur and cause off-flavours.

Let the grains gently sink into the water. If you’re using finely ground additions (such as the polenta in the example bitter recipe) put that in last so the larger grain hulls can act as a filter at the bottom of the bag.

Brew in a Bag : Grains in Brew Pot

Stir the mash, again very gently, until the grains are submerged and wet.

brew in a bag : wetting grain

3. Mash

The other purpose of stirring is to ensure uniformity of water temperature. You’ll find that the mixture is much hotter towards the bottom, and that it’s difficult to truly measure its temperature.

If it’s cooled significantly during the previous stage (quite likely) add more heat to bring the wort back to temperature. Put the lid on and leave according to the mash schedule, 70 minutes in the example recipe.

brew in a bag : checking temperature

When the time has elapsed lift the bag from the wort and drain, holding it close to the beer’s surface and taking care not to splash and introduce air.

When the wort starts to drip rather than pour from the bag I usually drop it into the fermentation bucket (fitted with another colander style false bottom) so it can self-drain for twenty minutes or so.

You’ll usually get another litre or two of wort by doing this, which you can pour back into the brew pot.

brew in a bag : secondary draining

You’ve made the wort. If you’re familiar with extract or beer kit brewing, you’re at the point you would be after adding the tin of malt. The following steps should be familiar.

brew in a bag : wort

4. Boil

Bring the wort fully to the boil before beginning the hop additions. Once it’s vigorously bubbling you’ll see a yellowy foam form on the surface. These are proteins joining together and leaving the liquid in a process called the hot break.

brew in a bag : boil

Follow the schedule of your recipe to add the bittering and flavouring hops.

5. Cool the Wort, Quickly

A key factor in getting a clear beer is how quickly you cool it after boiling. This stage is the cold break, where more proteins are forced from the wort. I use a bathtub filled with ice bottles for a cooling, but if you have one use a wort chiller.

brew in a bag : cooling

While the cooling down takes place, prepare the yeast. The example recipe uses dried yeast and this needs to be rehydrated in around 200ml sterilised water.

brew in a bag : hydrating the yeast

6. Pitch the Yeast

Once the beer is cool transfer it to the fermenting bucket.

It should be close to fermentation temperature, which for most people is room temperature.

Pour it several times between the bucket and the brew pot to aerate it. This will make it easier for the yeast to multiply and ferment the beer.

This is the only time when air should be in contact with the wort.

Of course, sanitise the fermenter before adding the beer.

Unless you used a hop bag, it’s a good idea to pass the wort through a sieve the first time it’s poured into the bucket. Otherwise, the hop and hot break debris will remain in the beer.

Although it shouldn’t affect the taste too much (unless you leave it fermenting for several weeks), it could cause problems during bottling if the gunk is sucked through the siphon and clogs it.

brew in a bag : aerated wort in fermenter

Put the lid on the fermenter and leave for around two weeks before priming and bottling.

brew in a bag fermenting bucket

Final Thoughts

Here are a few more things to consider as you’re trying brew in a bag for yourself:

  • The temperature is hard to control. Be careful not to overheat the water because it will cool very slowly, and unwanted tannins will be extracted from the malt if it’s too hot. You can always add more heat if you undershoot.
  • Drops of wort dribble everywhere when you remove the bag from the pot. Put something down to protect your stove if you’re worried about that.
  • Because of the relatively unrefined filtering technique brew in a bag beer can be a bit cloudy, especially if you wring every last drop of wort out of the grains. To counter this add whirlfloc or Irish moss for the last ten minutes of the boil.
  • The bag can get extremely hot and heavy when full of water so take care with your hands. It should be big enough to sit comfortably in the water while leaving enough dry fabric for you to grip.

If you have any questions, leave a comment.

Otherwise, try this simple brewing technique and enjoy!

  • If you enjoyed this post, enter your email address to find out about future updates:


  1. dale dudley


    your instructions look great I’m doing kits at moment which I’m enjoying….I’m thinking of beginning my own all grain brewing looking into various ways of building mash tuns etc…Came across this boil in the back method…looks like a great stepping stone to get the idea behind it before making that next step..I already have the equipment from kit brewing…..
    so I’m going to give this a try and see how i get on….

    just a few questions before I get started…..firstly i have book about brewing the beer you love ie recipes for shop bought brew like john smiths, Boddingtons etc….all the recipes are for 5 gallon only how would i convert them to 1-2 gallons i would guess that i would divide the recipe by 5 then x that by how many gallons i want to make? but i guess that’s too easy… i guessing correctly or is there a formula to work out the amounts when reducing I’ve already read from your website that you add an extra 30-50%more than target volume is there anything else to think about? i want to make the recipes from this book but in smaller volumes using the boil in the bag method is that possible?

    I look forward to your answer

    Dale :)

    • John

      Hi Dale,

      Here are some answers to your questions:

      Converting recipes
      Resizing is not quite as simple as a straight division and multiplication, but almost. It’s slightly different for hops and malt.

      Recipes usually give malt quantities based on a particular efficiency, which varies from brewer to brewer. Efficiency is the amount of sugar you get out of malt in the mash (soaking in water) versus the full amount of sugar available.

      For your first brew you don’t know your efficiency, so might as well follow the recipe exactly. This does mean simply dividing the malt quantity by 5 and multiplying by your target volume.

      To find out your efficiency for future brews take a gravity reading of the wort before you pitch the yeast. Then enter the recipe and gravity reading into Hopville (or another brewing programme) to compare your gravity with the expected one, and find out your efficiency.

      After 4 or 5 brews an average will emerge and you can adjust your recipes to suit.

      To convert the hops you need to take into account the alpha acid units rather than the weight. This page has more information on those calculations.

      Target Volume
      When you say add 30-50% I think you’re talking about the starting volume of water, right?

      You need to allow for evaporation, absorption by the grain and losses to trub (hop and yeast debris that settles to the bottom during fermentation).

      Again, this is something that varies from brewer to brewer and brew to brew. If your stove is super efficient, for example, and brings wort to the boil quickly you lose less to evaporation. Making a stronger beer (with more malt) you lose more to grain, and so on.

      To give you a rough idea, for an average brew I make about 14 litres (3.7 gallons) of beer starting with 21 litres (5.5 gallons) of water.

      If you want to get into a lot of detail with this I’ve had good results with Brewtarget, but it’s not really necessary unless you’re especially concerned.

      Is it possible to brew recipes from your book using brew in a bag?
      Yes! Because of the efficiency and water loss variables, the first couple of batches may come out weaker, stronger or more or less bitter than expected, but after that you should be able to match a given recipe pretty consistently.

      Good luck and thanks for stopping by!

  2. Ted

    Before you boil, is it really that important to not stir? The oxidation should be pretty minimal and you do oxygenate the wort for the yeast to propagate right?

    • John

      Hi Ted, thanks for the question.

      There’s nothing wrong with stirring the malt during the mash, in fact I find it improves efficiency by getting rid of dry pockets.

      The important thing is to use gentle and fluid movements and avoid introducing air to the wort. Even if the oxidation risk is small, I prefer not to leave it to chance because any air that gets in can bond with elements of the wort and cause cardboardy off-flavours.

      It’s during the mash that this is really an issue. Just before the boil the risk of oxidation is not the same, although I don’t find I need to stir then anyway.

      The aeration before adding the yeast is slightly different. Because the wort’s cool (below 27°C/80°F), the oxygen doesn’t bond in the same way – it’s taken in temporarily. As you say, it’s there to promote good yeast growth.

      That’s how I understand it – hope it helps.

  3. Alexandre

    I’m a begginer and found this way very interesting, mainly to the reduced tuns and equipments needed. Could you tell us which efficiency have you reached with this method? Congratulations for this tips!

    • John

      Hi Alexandre,

      Thanks for visiting.

      I average about 70% efficiency although I’ve had as much as 80-85%.

      When I first started with BIAB I had trouble with efficiency and wrote about it here.

      The main things I’ve found that increase it are:

      • Mixing well at the start to make sure there aren’t any dry patches of grain
      • Mashing for ninety minutes
      • Draining the bag into the fermentor while I heat the wort, moving the grains around every now and again to get out all the liquid. I add this to the rest before the boil.


  4. Arnie

    I’m about to try my first BIAB. I became confused about hopping when I saw some contraptions on line that consisted of a 5 inch ABS or PVC coupling with a 5 gallon paint straining bag attached. Unless I misunderstood, it appears that the hops are all thrown into the bag at the specific intervals and remained in the wort for the entire boil time. I always have put the specifc hops in separate bags, boiled for the recommended duration and then removed the hop bag before introducing the next variety. Am I missing something here? Please advise. Appreciate you help.

    • John

      Hi Arnie,

      Thanks for stopping by.

      Do you have a link to one of the contraptions? I don’t think I’ve come across those before.

      Usually when hops are added they’re left in the wort for the rest of the boil. It depends on the recipe, but it would be unusual for the hops to be removed before adding the next variety.

      Nearly all recipes state hop additions in time from the end of the boil. For example:

      25g Fuggles for 60 mins
      25g Kent Goldings for 20 mins
      25g Kent Goldings for 5 mins

      With this recipe you throw in the Fuggles 60 minutes before you want to finish. This is usually at the start of the boil. The Kent Goldings go in 40 minutes later, 20 minutes before the end of the boil. 15 minutes later, 5 minutes before the end, you add the final Kent Goldings.

      By the time you finish all of the hops are in the wort together.

      I don’t personally use hop bags because I separate the hop debris at the end with a sieve. If you can easily open your bag during the boil, there’s no need to separate the hop varieties.

      I hope that answers your question – please let me know if not.


  5. Roy

    I have just done my first brew in a bag and was amazed how much easier than using a tun etc. it was. Conversion was complete after a 90 min mash (iodine test) and I found it just as efficient as using a tun so I don’t think I will use a tun again. If you can hang the bag over the boiler on a rope fixed to a hook above and let it drip for a while after mashing is over its a big help. As a rule of thumb I find 1kg of mashed pale malt will give you 1% abv in a 5 gallon (22.5l) brew. I know some people do better but I never have.

    • John

      Roy, Thanks for sharing your experience and the handy rule of thumb.

      I’ve found the drainage stage to be very useful for getting efficiency up. The wort that drips out is high gravity, at least on my system, and makes a big difference overall.

      I usually leave the bag in the fermenter while bringing the wort to the boil, and then pour the extra in at the last minute.


  6. Brett

    Great article. Brew in a bag beers have taken off so many prizes in competitions now that there doesn’t seem to be an argument that the beer is in any way inferior.

    Another Aussie discovery is No Chill. The fact is, you DON’T have to chill quickly to create cold break. So for a 24 litre (6 gallon) batch I use a 20 litre food grade water container (they have a little headroom), sanitise it, then drain the hot wort directly into the container, squeeze out any air if possible, and seal. It’s recommended to tip it on its side for a few minutes because the hot wort is an additional opportunity to sterilise the lid. It will cool down to the correct temp in about 24 hours, but you can keep it in the container for much longer safely.
    * No infections
    * Excellent separation of cold break.
    * Pitch yeast when you’re ready
    * Quicker brew day
    * No-chill container (water container) costs about $12!

    • John

      Brett, thanks for the suggestion.

      I’ve heard about No Chill but have never tried it. You’ve made a convincing argument, so I’ll be sure to give it a go at some point soon.

      A commenter on another post is experimenting with no boil brewing at the moment. I’m not sure how that’s turned out yet, but all these things together could make for a very efficient brew day. Great for brewing in the evening when time’s tight.


  7. dan

    I can confirm that the no chill method is most definitely the way forward I have been doing biab with no chill for about 4 years and touch wood have never had an infection, and as our water is metered I could not justify literately throwing money down the drain. there is truth in the saying old habits die hard, but in my opinion biab and no chill go hand in hand.

    • John

      Thanks for sharing that, Dan.

      The more I hear about no chill the more tempted I am to try it.


  8. David

    Is it important to have a Second filtration process?

    • John


      Draining the wort from the brew bag, after you remove it from the pot, is fairly important. Usually a high proportion of the fermentable sugars are in there.

      Is that what you meant?

      • David

        Yeah. That’s what I was asking. Should I pour water over the grain bag while it is draining to help get out any final sugars?

        • John

          You may get a few more gravity points out of it by doing that, but I personally don’t think it’s worth it.

          After experimenting with various rinsing options, I’ve come to the conclusion that draining while lightly turning the grains over inside the bag best balances results with effort.

          The difference between doing or not doing it is big, and the draining fits naturally into brew day. You can leave it dripping into the fermenting bucket while bringing the rest of the wort to boil.

          On the other hand, to rinse you’d need another pot to heat more water, and the few extra points won’t make a great deal of difference to your gravity.

          That’s what I’ve found anyway. It’s definitely something worth experimenting with as you brew more.

          Hope that helps.

        • Roy

          I find it a good idea to pour a 3 or 4 pints of warm water over the bag while it is draining and have had no problems with doing this.

          • John

            I haven’t found the extra rinse to make a big difference, but it’s interesting to hear it’s not the same for everyone. It goes to show it’s worth experimenting, and fine tuning your brewing.

            Thanks for joining in.

        • Roy

          I am using a home made plastic boiler using a couple of kettle elements and did have problems with keeping the temperature right. I have now made a controller using a Simmerstat to control one of the elements will I do my 90 mins. mash. You can get these on eBay for about £10 and its not too much of a job to mount one in a box of some sort. Make sure you get the wiring diagram to go with the one you get as they are not all the same. This fixed my temperature control and it now stays with a few degrees of ideal for as long as I want.

          • John


            Thank you very much for sharing your experience. It’s great to hear about other ways of doing things, and that sounds a useful way of controlling temperature. It can be tricky on a regular stove.


  9. peter

    Hi John just about to try my first brew in a bag attempt ,what advise for recipe for a beginner with his first brew

    • John

      Hi Peter,

      In a way it depends what you’d like to drink. You can brew most types of beer fairly easily with the basic technique.

      Having said that, if I were you I’d keep it simple while you’re getting the hang of brew day. These recipes are pretty straightforward:

      Light and hoppy
      Dark brown and malty
      Bitter (leave out the corn and make it even simpler)

      Hope that helps, let me know if not.

      Good luck.


  10. Charlie

    Do you ever do some ‘sparging’ of the grain while you’re letting it drain into the fermentor?

    • Charlie

      Sorry just saw you answered this already! Sounds like its a personal preference thing that could increase efficiency slightly but not entirely necessary?

      • John

        Hi Charlie,

        I’ve never found it to be necessary. At one point I was fairly obsessive about measuring gravity at each stage of the brew and I just didn’t find the extra hassle of preparing sparge water worth it. Yes, I got more gravity points but spread over twenty litres of beer it wasn’t enough to make much difference.

        I do rake over the grain with a spoon several times though, because the wort left in the grains after you remove the bag is usually very high gravity.

        Thanks for the question.

  11. Chris

    Hi, I am attempting my first BIAB in the next couple of days and just wanted to ask for some tips! I have read through the comments and have taken a lot of the information in! I have a electric stainless steel mash tin that will do my mash within 2-3 degrees of ideal temp (tested with plain water) and this will boil. I’m planning on doing a 5 gal batch of hoegaarden clone as I’m quite picky with my beers and want something tasty, I have recently purchased the book beer captured with some of the recipes in. I live in Hertfordshire and I not sure about my water quality, would this affect my brew in any way and shall I use bottled water ? Some people say this massively affects the quality of the beer. Also I have made a wort chiller using a guide I found on YouTube, the copper does Smell metally.. Will this affect the flavour in any way? Also when it comes to fermentation I have read different views of primary and secondary fermentation. I have one 30litre fermentation bucket. Will I require a second one ? Thanks for you help hope to hear from you soon!


    • John

      Hi Chris,

      In answer to your questions:

      There shouldn’t be a need to use bottled water unless your tap water tastes particularly bad. I’ve heard it said somewhere that if it’s good enough to drink it’s good enough to brew with. If you have a lot of chlorine in the water that can be a particularly strong taste, but you can let that clear by leaving the water to stand for about a day beforehand.

      I’ve never used a wort chiller so can’t comment, but plenty of people do which I guess means they don’t ruin the beer!

      I wrote a little about primary/secondary fermentation here. I don’t think you’ll need a second bucket, but there are others who would disagree.

      Hope that helps.

      • Chris

        Thank you for taking the time to answer my questions ! This website is awesome !

        • John


  12. Noobie noob

    Hi, I’m new and later this week going to embark on my first brew day. I was wondering if you could help me by answering a few questions, cheers! Most of these are probably kind of silly…

    I have the grain bill all set up for 1-3 gallon batches over the next few weeks, I’m going to be using a ~3 litre colander to separate the grains from the wort instead of a bag, I also bought a stainless steel colander to increase the distance of the grains from the bottom of the pot, I’m wondering if there is any point in the false since I’m not using a bag currently (i.e. are scorched grains still a possibility or will this pot just get in the way of initial stirring?

    Any insight if would you recommend I recirculate the wort through the through the strained wort and/or sparge using this method.

    Sorry it’s not a question close to your method (I think), I’m just excited and most of the people using the biab method seem to use a colander in the bottom of the pot (do you keep this in the kettle too?).

    Thanks again, sorry for the rambling!

    • John

      Yes, I use a colander in the bottom of the pot as the grains tend to sink to the bottom. As long as there’s some liquid above it you should be able to stir effectively.

      I’m not sure how you’ll manage with the colander and no bag. The grains have a fair amount of fine debris with them that I imagine will get through. Is there a particular reason you don’t want to use a bag?

      I haven’t found a measurable benefit from recirculating wort or sparging. It’s definitely worth fully draining the grains, but an additional rinse doesn’t pay back the extra time and effort (in my experience).

      Hope that helps. Good luck.

  13. Chris

    Hi john,

    I recently brewed a Hoegaarden clone and have just recently racked into a secondary vessel (am aware of the discussions but just wanted to check and see what happens for myself! Plus was dying to spend a bit of cash on equipment :P ). As I was syphoning into secondary I decided to taste the beer. It smells chemically and a mild similar taste. Still tastes like beer though however nothing like Hoegaarden. The recipe I used was from a book called Beer Captured. Will this improve when I bottle and condition the beer? During moving of the wort into primary fermentation vessel, I needed to move the primary vessel, I lifted the bucket which sucked some sanitizer solution into the brew through the airlock. This solution was quite concentrated could this be the reason for the strange taste and smell ?
    I just hope it improves. I have brewed extract beers before and this was my first all grain BIAB method. The beer did have stuff floating on the surface, not much but i did notice some scum like stuff. Do you think it will be ok ??

    The yeast I used was a wyeast 3463 forbidden fruit in the activator packaging.

    Thanks for your help!


    • John

      Hi Chris,

      There’s a good chance the beer will be fine, yes. It often tastes relatively rough half way through, although usually if it’s going to be great you have an inkling early on.

      If you sucked through a large amount of sanitizer that could be it (what sort do you use?) although if it’s just the amount that was in the airlock you should be OK (unless it was bleach).

      I wouldn’t worry about the stuff on the surface, that’s perfectly normal. The chemical taste could be a result of the yeast.

      I’d leave the beers a good while to settle down and the chances are they’ll be fine.

      Hope it turns out OK. BIAB is great once you get into it.



      • Chris

        Hi John,

        Thanks for replying. The sanitiser I used was VWP? I’m going to use vodka from now on to help prevent this/ or just try not to move the fermenter. I’m
        Going to bottle in a couple weeks and will leave for at least a month in bottles.. If I can avoid the temptation! I’m going to repeat the recipe at the weekend but use dried peel I got from my LHBS instead of the fresh peel I used, as my first attempt does smell very Orangy! :)

        I did a different batch yesterday using a leffe clone recipe. I didn’t quite reach my target mash tempretures. I think my strike water temp (68-70) wasn’t hot enough and after I added my grains it went down to around 58-60 degrees and stayed there, ( about 6kgs of grain!) also I was using a electric mash tin/boiler. I did try to increase the tempreture but I think there was too much grains in my tin and would start to boil the portion closest to the element at the bottom of the tin, ( I think the grains created a layer of water underneath) I was constantly monitoring it over it’s 90min mash but I just hope that the few seconds of boiling the bottom dont effect the end result !

        Thanks again for this great website it’s like my brewing bible lol..


        • John

          Hi Chris,

          It sounds like you’re making good progress.

          Hope the beers turn out well!


  14. Calum


    I’m planning my first BIAB and I have all the grains for the recipe. My only problem is that I don’t have a pot big enough to fill the correct amount of water compared with grain.

    Would it be possible to add the correct amount of grain to the small amount of water and add water after? Or would it work if I converted the recipe to the amount of water I can use and do it twice in order to use all the grain and produce the same amount of beer? Or would it be best if I just spent the money on a bigger pot? (I’m a beginner so I really have no idea!)



    • John

      Hi Calum,

      Probably it would be better to get a bigger pot!

      Failing that, I know it would work to do two small batches with scaled down ingredient quantities. The only problem you have there is time.

      I’ve not tried using less water with the same amount of grain so I don’t know how it would work. I expect it would be OK in general, but you may end up being less efficient.

      Even with a full size pot the grains are fairly densely packed in the water so your pot would still have to be fairly big. Otherwise some of the grain may not get wet enough.

      I’d give a go if I were you. It may work and that would save the expense of a new brew pot. I’d be interested to know how you get on.

      Good luck.

  15. jim fisher

    I have 30 batches of extract brewing under my belt. I am ready to start brew in a bag.

    I wonder if preheating the grains in an oven at 150F degrees just before putting it in the 150F kettle would help with getting your water temperature exactly right? I brew over a propane tank and getting it just right is a chore sometimes.

    • John

      Hi Jim,

      Personally I find overheating slightly and adjusting temperature on the fly to be OK, but it’s always worth tweaking your methods if you’re not happy with them.

      I wonder whether you would introduce a toasted flavour (even if only slight) to the beer too.

      Thanks for the comment.

  16. Anthony

    once mash temp is reached can you still add heat if temp drops below desired and can h2o be added to fermentor to make up difference for 5 gallon batch? for instance if the starting h20 is 5.5 and add 10 lbs if grain there will be approx 3.5 gallons if h20 remaining. can i start the boil and add h2o to top off in the fermentor? ur answer is greatly appreciated. thank you very much.

    • John


      Yes, you can add heat if the temperature drops. It’s usually a balancing act all the way through the mash.

      You can also add water, although ideally you will boil it beforehand. This can make it slightly awkward to do unless you have a spare brew pot. It is easier to start with more water.

      Hope that helps.

      • Anthony

        Thank you very much for taking time our and replying. I do have one more quick question. Once the temp reaches the desired mash temp with BIAB can it be placed in an oven at that temp to hold for the desired time? this way no babysitting the temp high and low. it will make it easier but is it doable or recommended? :-) that was last question, I promise. Happy 4th!!!!

        • John

          I don’t see why that wouldn’t work if your oven is stable at low temperatures, and it’s big enough for your brew pot. I’ve never tried it myself though.

          It’s not that bad on the stove top. As long as you overheat at the beginning, it generally maintains the temperature pretty well.

          Hope the oven works out if you try it.

  17. Eddie

    If you mis-calculate the total amount of water needed and end up short, can you simply add sterile water to make up the difference?

    • John

      Yes you can, or you can leave it as a stronger beer.

  18. Finished BIAB and happened to get approx. 82% efficiency. (Chemistry degree paid off LOL) I asked for the grains to be double ground. Also, recipe called for7.5 gallons of total water. I have 8 gallon kettle so placing all water and grain would have spilled over. Time to get creative. Figured out the amount in gallons of 5 gallons plus grains (aprox 6.5 gallons) heated 2 more pots (1.25 gallons each) of H2O to 168 F for sparging- brought grain temp to 162F – turned heat off – placed bag and grains – held for 70 mins – lifted bag and set on colander on top of brew kettle – sparged with 168F H2O until kettle reached 6 gallons (took 2 gallons – had .5 extra which i could have used but didn’t need ) – started to boil for 60 min – boil off about 1 gallon – 5 gallons in fermenter

    Recipe : OPA Pale Ale
    8.1 lb American – Pale 2-Row
    1 lb American – Munich – Dark 20L
    0.5 lb American – Caramel / Crystal 30L
    0.4 lb American – Carapils (Dextrine Malt)
    0.5 oz Cascade 60
    0.5 oz Amaril 15
    0.5 oz Galaxy 10
    0.5 oz Cascade 5

  19. Wow. Thanks for this article. It really made the entire process clear (and with a minimum of jargon). I’ve been considering going all grain for a while now but have been put off by the expense and apparent complexity. But now… I’m going to give BIAB a shot on my next brew day. Seems like, at the very least, it will help inform my decision making around all grain brewing.

    • John

      Thanks. I hope you enjoy trying it.

  20. John

    Hi john,
    First let me thank you for the time and effort you put in this website.
    secondly, i yearn for a veteran’s guidance such as yourself in this predicament of mine, you see i live in a country where alcohol/ethanol is illegal, and for that i suffer badly, so i got some non-alcoholic beers, sugar, bakers yeast (the only yeast i could find).
    Bought a brewing glass bottle w/airlock, poured 3 liters of beer, 125 grams of sugar, and around 20 grams of active dry yeast (fleischmann’s), this is the second day, the beer looks to be fermenting as the airlock bubbles repeatedly, but the gases seemed to lessen a lot since yesterday! and the beer looks cloudy, very very cloudy!!
    im keeping the bottle in room temperature (17 C), away from sun light.
    any advice/help would be greatly appreciated.

    • John

      Hi John,

      If alcohol is illegal where you live, have you thought about trying to improve the quality of the non-alcoholic beer?

      Brew Dog have recently released a collection of their recipes which includes “Nanny State”, a non-alcoholic beer, which I have heard is good.

      • John

        Thanks for the reply but, john, a non-alcoholic beer is hardly a beer, so im asking for guidance here if my methods are correct or not, and as an update the tinged cloudiness has subsided from the top of the jar! i guess hooray thats some good news right?
        i implore you to enlighten me of a process easy enough to do at home, converting non to alcoholic.

  21. Jerrt

    Hi John,

    Do you reccommend adding salt additions to the water after it is heated to mashing temp? I have read some people mix it in with the grains and some have put it in before. I am brewing an IPA and need a low HCO3 amount and my local water is quite high therefore I am using 70% distilled water and adding salts.


    • John

      Hi Jerrt,

      I have always been happy enough with the water I use so do not add salts. Therefore I’m afraid I can’t give you an answer based on experience.

      After you’ve tried it, please let us know how you got on.


  22. James

    I’ve been brewing with kits for years now and have finally had enough of mediocre beer so have ordered a BIAB kit. I can hardly wait!

    Because I’m so impatient: can BIAB all grain make just as gooder beer as a boutique micro brewery commercial beer can? I see no reason why not.

    • John

      Yes, with practice.

  23. Dale

    Hi John,

    Great post!

    Was just about to do my first traditional all grain this weekend when I read about brew in a bag. Decided to try this method instead as it sounds a little less involved.

    So my question; once the grain has been mashed in and the lid is on, do I switch the gas off or do I need to have the gas on and keep it at temp for the mash period?

    Secondly, with dry yeast is it recommended to bring it to life with water or is it fine to pitch dry. All the extract recipes have said pitch it dry which has worked fine but wondering if you can pitch it wet and if you can is it better to? If so, why?



    • John

      Hi Dale,

      Generally the temperature holds, so switch the gas off, but keep an eye on the temperature as you may need to give it a boost in the middle.

      Here is an answer to your second question.

      Good luck.